20 Comments
User's avatar
Erin Khar's avatar

LOVE this and I agree... museums are a balm for creative blocks, anxieties, etc!

Expand full comment
Beth Bonness's avatar

Love the suggestion of spending time at a museum. I imagine doing some edits among the works of art too. What a great metaphor for a work-in-progress, the initial sketch.

Expand full comment
Lorne Daniel's avatar

“The shape of the thing” in a sketch. This is great observation, Lilly. Thanks.

Expand full comment
Kelly Morgan's avatar

With Hopper's three preliminary drawings of Nighthawks, you've given us an invaluable tool, a searing image of his increasingly detailed iterations necessary to a final work of art. They're going above my desk. Thank you!

Expand full comment
Jenn McKee's avatar

This is so helpful (and beautifully conveyed) - exactly what I needed to read today. Thanks for sharing this perspective!

Expand full comment
Jennifer Dines's avatar

Truly a wonderful craft essay...as others have said, this is just what I needed for approaching my own writing today. In fact, I was procrastinating writing by reading this. :)

Expand full comment
Trish Deveneau's avatar

Such a great example of understanding the creative process as it takes shape in one’s own work! Looking forward to your “final draft.”

Expand full comment
Jane Marcellus's avatar

This made me realize I really need to spend time in a museum. Thank you.

Expand full comment
Victoria Olsen's avatar

This piece has a lovely sort of arc -- from anxious to calm-- but we see how you get from one to the other, gradually, and how well earned it is through the art itself. Thanks! (Funny coincidence, but I wrote a post about visiting the Whitney too this week -- and mentioned your book as a resource.)

Expand full comment
Lilly Dancyger's avatar

oh amazing, thank you!

Expand full comment
veryscreaming's avatar

This just helped my life, thank you.

Expand full comment
M.C. Calvera's avatar

This appeared in my inbox at the perfect moment. LOVED it, thank you for sharing!

Expand full comment
Jessie Sholl's avatar

I love this so much, Lilly! Thank you.

Expand full comment
Elka Wilder's avatar

Thank you so much for this beautiful piece, Lilly. Just what I needed to hear in my process.

Expand full comment
Rona Maynard's avatar

Words and images, two wellsprings that nourish each other. What a fascinating project this will be for writer and (speaking of nourishing each other).

Expand full comment
Rona Maynard's avatar

I meant to say “writer and reader.” Excitement got the better of me.

Expand full comment
Kathryn A. LeRoy's avatar

The comparison to early sketches and early writing drafts has haunted me all day. I will never look at those early attempts of words and story in quite the same way. I will keep the images of Hopper's sketches as a reminder that every work of art must begin with a framework, a sketch, the building blocks of potential. The drafts on my desk look so different now.

Expand full comment
Lilly Dancyger's avatar

Ah, thank you Kathryn!!

Expand full comment
Eileen Drennen's avatar

What brilliant observations about the overlaps / processes of visual art and writing, Lilly! Actually read the Sargent piece first and find both so uniquely helpful. Love being able to share in your process of discovery as you find your way to the heart of your questions in these images.

Expand full comment
Lilly Dancyger's avatar

Thanks Eileen!!

Expand full comment